Compare Bosley Shampoo vs Nioxin for hair growth
Looking at Bosley Shampoo vs Nioxin is like comparing apples and oranges. While both claim to improve your hair, each takes a very different approach, and unique corporate philosophies. Bosley made a name for themselves with hair transplants and laser treatments. Nioxin is focused on natural treatments and thinking of your scalp as skin that needs to be cared for to properly grow hair. Considering those differing approches to treating hair loss which is better, Bosley shampoo vs Nioxin?
|What Is It||Hair & scalp cleaning shampoo||Hair growth system|
|What it Does||Creates a healthy environment for thicker, fuller-looking hair||Provides existing hair with a blend of proprietary vitamins and minerals and promotes new growth|
|Clinical Studies||0 (at lest none that we could find)||0 (at lest none that we could find)|
|Age of Company||40+ years||25 years|
Bosley was started by Doctor Lee Bosley in 1974. Doctor Bosley was a pioneer in the field of hair transplants which is what Bosley is still primarily known for. They have 70 locations throughout North America, with corporate headquarters in Beverly Hills, California. Bosley has also branched into non-surgical hair loss treatments such as the FDA approved Laser Comb Elite, scalp micopigmentation, and topical hair loss treatments. Knowing that Bosley has traditionally focused on surgical hair loss treatments how does Bosley Shampoo vs Nioxin compare when considering what Nioxin focuses on?
Nioxin Labs were founded by Eva Graham in 1987 with the goal of using exfoliates and anti-aging ingredients to enhance your scalp and develop healthier-looking hair. During their 30+ year history Nioxin has shown a commitment to using healthy natural ingredients in their products. This is a great change from some of their chemical laden competitors. You can read the full company history on their brand heritage page.
Nioxin promotes a suite of hair care products including shampoo, conditioner, leave ins, supplements, and salon treatments. Nioxin is based on using natural ingredients to improve your scalp. They believe that scalp care is just as important as regular skin care. Nioxin uses a system they call 3D which nourishes your derma (your scalp), and manages hair density and diameter. Caring for DERMA, DENSITY, and DIAMETER makes up the Nioxin 3D System. This is an important fact to consider when looking at Bosley Shampoo vs Nioxin.
In 2012 researchers from the University of Rome set out to determine if saw palmetto could inhibit the 5-alpha reductase enzyme. Participants received 320mg of saw palmetto every day for 24 months. At the conclusion of the study 38% of patients that received saw palmetto noticed an increase in hair growth. Another study in 2002 documented that 60% of the participants experienced an increase in hair growth after taking saw palmetto. Considering this information there is reason to believe that saw palmetto found in LifeXtend could help some people control and possibly improve hair loss.
While Bosley uses saw palmetto, Nioxin hangs their hat on a combination of peppermint oil, nettle leaf, and saw palmetto. A 2014 study proved that peppermint oil can impact hair growth on mice. This is believed to be due to increased circulation. In regard to nettle leaf researchers believe it contains anti-inflammatory properties that could improve circulation on the scalp. Nioxin appears to back up their commitment to natural products with a combination of products with a history of hair growth.
Reviewing Bosley Shampoo vs Nioxin revels two companies with similar goals but very different product strategies. Both have proven track records helping patients overcome hair loss. Bosley mostly accomplishes this through hair transplants and they are now branching into a bit more natural products. Nioxin was founded on the basis of natural products and has stayed the course. So while both can help regrow hair this is mostly a decision on which company aligns with your personal feelings. Consider the cited studies above and make the decision that is right for you. As always please consult with your doctor before starting a new medication or health care product.